A great activity for everyone


By Jon Zajac

As a fan of the hit TV show Supernatural, I’m always looking for ways to incorporate its themes of adventure, friendship, and the supernatural into my events. One fun way to do this is by using Supernatural-themed “This or That” icebreaker questions. By asking questions related to the show’s characters, storylines, and themes, you can create a sense of excitement and intrigue among your guests and encourage them to share their opinions and experiences.

How to incorporate Supernatural themed This or That questions

To incorporate Supernatural-themed “This or That” questions into your event, follow these steps:

  1. Prepare a list of questions beforehand that are related to the show’s characters, storylines, and themes. You can find inspiration from watching episodes, reading recaps, or browsing online forums and fan sites.

  2. Print out the questions on cards or display them on a screen or a poster board. Encourage your guests to form small groups of 3-5 people and take turns asking each other the questions. You can also create a rotation system where each group moves on to the next question after a set amount of time (e.g., 2-3 minutes).

  3. Make sure everyone has a chance to answer each question and listen actively to their responses. Encourage follow-up questions, comments, and discussions that build on the initial answers. You can also share your own insights and opinions about the show to keep the conversation flowing.

  4. After everyone has had a chance to answer all the questions, gather your guests in a larger group and ask them to share their favorite or most surprising answers. You can also use this opportunity to highlight any commonalities or connections that emerged during the activity.

  5. Consider using some of the insights or stories that came up during the “This or That” icebreaker as a springboard for further conversations and activities throughout the day. For example, you could organize a trivia game based on Supernatural trivia or create a photo booth with props inspired by the show’s characters and settings.

Ideas on different themes of questions

To keep your Supernatural-themed icebreaker questions fresh and engaging, you can explore different themes and categories that are relevant to the show. Here are some ideas:

  • Characters: Ask questions related to the personalities, relationships, and quirks of the show’s main characters (e.g., “Which Supernatural character do you relate to the most?” or “Who is your favorite hunter?”).

  • Storylines: Ask questions about the show’s plot twists, conflicts, and resolutions (e.g., “What was your favorite season of Supernatural?” or “Do you prefer the monster-of-the-week episodes or the overarching storylines?”).

  • Themes: Ask questions that explore the show’s themes and messages (e.g., “What lessons have you learned from watching Supernatural?” or “How has Supernatural changed your perspective on good vs. evil?”).

  • Humor: Ask questions that tap into the show’s comedic style and humor (e.g., “Which Supernatural character makes you laugh the most?” or “What is your favorite funny moment from the show?”).

  • Supernatural elements: Ask questions that reference the show’s mythology, lore, and supernatural creatures (e.g., “What is your favorite type of monster in Supernatural?” or “Which supernatural power would you like to have?”).

By incorporating these different themes of questions into your Supernatural-themed icebreaker activity, you can keep your guests engaged and entertained while also fostering a sense of excitement and curiosity. So why not give it a try and see how it can enhance your next event!

My favorite Supernatural themed This or That questions

  1. Dean or Sam?
  2. Impala or angel wings?
  3. Salt or iron?
  4. Bobby or Charlie?
  5. Hunting ghosts or demons?
  6. Cas as an angel or Cas as a human?
  7. Salt and burn or exorcism?
  8. Crowley or Lucifer?
  9. Death or Michael?
  10. Salt circle or Devil’s trap?
  11. Mary Winchester or John Winchester?
  12. Leviathan or Eve?
  13. Alpha vampire or Dick Roman?
  14. Charlie as a hacker or Charlie as a hunter?
  15. Wendigo or Skinwalker?
  16. Dean’s amulet or Sam’s demon blood powers?
  17. The Colt or Ruby’s knife?
  18. Benny or Garth?
  19. Jo Harvelle or Ellen Harvelle?
  20. Jody Mills or Sheriff Mills?
  21. Demon Dean or Soulless Sam?
  22. Rowena or Meg?
  23. The Trickster or Gabriel?
  24. Ghost Bobby or Apocalypse Bobby?
  25. Lucifer in the cage or Michael in the cage?
  26. Abaddon or Cain?
  27. Hell Hounds or Black Eyes?
  28. Kevin Tran or Charlie Bradbury?
  29. The British Men of Letters or the American Hunters?
  30. Jack as a baby or Jack as a teenager?
  31. Chuck as God or Chuck as a writer?

About the author

Jon Zajac

Jon Zajac

Founder & Chief Icebreaker

I started Icebreaker Spot because I truly believe that strong connections are the foundation of successful teams. I wanted to create a platform that would make it easy for people to find and share icebreakers and team building activities, empowering them to build trust, foster collaboration, and ultimately, achieve greatness together.